Cullen Law | Toll Free: 877.244.6420 | Local: 407.254.4901

Although cases where liability is clear are oftentimes easier to handle, we very regularly make recoveries for our clients when liability is disputed.  Fortunately, Florida is what is known as a comparative negligence state.  This means that at the conclusion of each personal injury jury trial, the jury will be asked to assign a percentage of fault to each party.  Whatever percentage of fault is assigned to any party other other than the Defendant is reduced from the Plaintiff's recovery. For example, assume that the Plaintiff has been injured in a car accident with two other cars.  The Plaintiff settled with Defendant #1, but the case against Defendant #2 goes to trial.  At trial, the jury decides that the Plaintiff has suffered damages in the amount of $100,000.00.  In addition, the jury decides that Defendant #1 was 50% responsible for causing the accident, and that Defendant #2 and the Plaintiff were each 25% responsible.  In this example, the Plaintiff would only collect $25,000.00 of the jury's $100,000.00 award.  The Plaintiff is not allowed to collect for his own negligence, or that of the Defendant he already settled with. Disputed liability cases can many times be resolved without the need of a trial, but it is important that the injury victim takes a realistic approach to the case.  A case with truly disputed liability is just not going to garner the same kind of result as a case with liability is clear. It should be noted that many times insurance companies and others will sometimes see a dispute in liability where one seemingly does not exist.  In cases such as these it is sometimes beneficial to hire an expert witness to clarify issues as they relate to liability.  In cases like these it is important to have an experienced lawyer who is familiar with the use of expert witnesses. 
I need a lawyer now I don't know if I need a lawyer I'm injured and I need information

If you have been wronged and think you have a right to compensation, you may have questions.

 


Q: The other driver is blaming me for the accident, but I think the other driver was at fault.  What should I do?  Can I still make a claim for my injuries even though liability is disputed?

A: Although cases where liability is clear are oftentimes easier to handle, we very regularly make recoveries for our clients when liability is disputed.  Fortunately, Florida is what is known as a comparative negligence state.  This means that at the conclusion of each personal injury jury trial, the jury will be asked to assign a percentage of fault to each party.  Whatever percentage of fault is assigned to any party other other than the Defendant is reduced from the Plaintiff's recovery.

For example, assume that the Plaintiff has been injured in a car accident with two other cars.  The Plaintiff settled with Defendant #1, but the case against Defendant #2 goes to trial.  At trial, the jury decides that the Plaintiff has suffered damages in the amount of $100,000.00.  In addition, the jury decides that Defendant #1 was 50% responsible for causing the accident, and that Defendant #2 and the Plaintiff were each 25% responsible.  In this example, the Plaintiff would only collect $25,000.00 of the jury's $100,000.00 award.  The Plaintiff is not allowed to collect for his own negligence, or that of the Defendant he already settled with.

Disputed liability cases can many times be resolved without the need of a trial, but it is important that the injury victim takes a realistic approach to the case.  A case with truly disputed liability is just not going to garner the same kind of result as a case with liability is clear.

It should be noted that many times insurance companies and others will sometimes see a "dispute" in liability where one seemingly does not exist.  In cases such as these it is sometimes beneficial to hire an expert witness to clarify issues as they relate to liability.  In cases like these it is important to have an experienced lawyer who is familiar with the use of expert witnesses. 



Law Offices of Kim Michael Cullen, P.A.
1219 E. Livingston St.
Orlando, FL 32803
Email: kcullen@cullen-law.com
Phone: 407-254-4901

This Orlando accident attorney represents clients across Florida including the following areas: 

Orlando, Winter Park, Maitland, Kissimmee, Casselberry, Altamonte Springs, Longwood, Lake Mary, Heathrow, Sanford, Winter Springs, Winter Garden, Clermont, Clearwater, Tampa, Lakeland, Cocoa Beach, Melbourne.  As well as Orange, Seminole, Osceola, Lake, Volusia, Brevard, Polk, Hillsborough, Pinellas, Sumter, and Marion Counties

Share |

Just Call
407.254.4901

1219 E. Livingston St. Orlando, FL 32803

Contact Us
First Name:

Phone:
Last Name:

Email:
©2010 Law Offices of Kim Michael Cullen, P.A., All Rights Reserved, Reproduced with Permission
Attorney website design by Foster Web Marketing, the best attorney website design solution on the Web offering search engine optimization for attorneys, lawyer website design, video for attorneys, and more.
Get SEO Tips from The Attorney Internet Marketing Blog